Misleading
Operating Statements
In the acquisition of an income producing
property an investor can safely assume that the
seller's initial price expectations exceed the property's
economic performance. An informed investor will make every
effort to establish a reliable Net Operating Income (NOI) that
will support a realistic purchase price. Net Operating
Income is a key factor in determining value. NOI is that sum
remaining after deducting vacancy allowance and operating
expenses from gross income.
The Ideal form for detailing income and
expenses is the Annual Property Operating Data (APOD) form
developed by The Commercial Investment Real Estate Institute,
it is highly recommended as an accurate method of examining
income and expenses. Since the Net Operating Income (NOI) plays
a key role in determining value, there are usually two sets of
income and expense figures at the outset of investment real
estate transactions...as outlined below. Continued
below
The first set of income and expense figures
are prepared by the seller and often reflect exaggerated income
and understated expenses arriving at an NOI that supports an
inflated asking price. Seldom if ever in a sellers income and
expense statement is a vacancy allowance considered. Routinely,
repairs and maintenance and property management expenses are
excluded because the seller personally handles property
management as well as repairs and maintenance. Often last
year's real estate taxes or fuel bills are indicated. It should
be expected that a sellers income and expense statement will
offer a higher NOI in order to command a higher sale price.
The second set of income and expense figures
should be a reconstructed statement, that of a prudent
purchaser utilizing the APOD form to arrive at a credible net
operating income that will support a reasonable purchase
price.
Income should be confirmed by reviewing
existing leases with an eye toward maximizing rental amounts. A
minimum vacancy factor of five percent can be included, a
management expense of at least five percent should be factored
in whether or not the purchaser intends to manage the property
personally. Depending on the age and condition of the building
and the tenant responsibilities specified in the leases, a
repairs and maintenance expense ranging from four percent to
eight percent might be considered. Real estate taxes as well as
general operating expenses should be anticipated to increase at
least two percent over current figures. Following these
guidelines in preparing a reconstructed income and expense
statement can contribute to the development of a dependable Net
Operating Income (NOI).
It is important to understand that net
operating income is the underpinning for every reliable method
of evaluating an income producing property. Whether it be a
capitalization method of establishing value (cap rates),
determining cash on cash return, internal rate of return or
investment value, net operating income is the very foundation
in establishing value.
About the
author: Stewart L. Mac Donald, CCIM, is President of
Real Estate Assets, Inc., a consulting services company
focused on maximizing wealth through Asset Management in
the real estate portfolio. Mr. Mac Donald has counseled on and
has been an active participant in a wide range of investment
real estate projects. He has written and presented seminars on
"Strategic Planning in the Investment Real Estate
Portfolio" before bar associations, financial planning and
investment groups.
http://www.real-assets.com
http://www.real-estate-assets.com
Return to Home Page
|